logoalt Hacker News

tegling • today at 8:56 AM • 6 replies • view on HN

Why must there be a dichotomy: "use AI/don't think for yourself", vs "don't use AI/think for yourself"?

I think we'll need to grow in our individual relationship with AI. Can't AI be that persuasive and contrarian, at times adversarial, friend? Someone you have to be somewhat wary of, but can provide very thoughtful, intelligent and challenging conversation? Such a "friend" obviously never replaces knowledge. If anything, you'll need to arm yourself with as much knowledge as possible to engage with that friend.


Replies

eloisius • today at 9:40 AM

Skipping the “friend” criticism as you’ve already addressed it in sibling comments, but another reason among many that even trying to use it as an adversarial interlocutor is flawed thinking, is that even if you prompt it to debate you, you’re the one still prompting it to do that. It can never _mean_ to contradict your argument with its own unique viewpoint. It can only argue because you gave it that prompt. Ironically it’s still a sycophantic position.

➕ show 3 replies
bryanrasmussen • today at 10:58 AM

>Why must there be a dichotomy: "use AI/don't think for yourself", vs "don't use AI/think for yourself"?

because studies show that use of AI in subject areas of which one has expertise consistently decreases that expertise? As these subject areas are generally ones with intellectual requirements "use AI" = "Don't Think for Yourself", which underlines well known common sense aphorisms such as "use it or lose it", where the it is the expertise that one stops to use in favor of AI. You lose your ability to think for yourself in your field of expertise, but you gain the AI.

➕ show 2 replies
lproven • today at 10:21 AM

> Can't AI be that persuasive and contrarian, at times adversarial, friend?

No. It generates text like that in its corpus. If there is a pattern that looks like the interaction you ask for, it will imitate it, but it can't be adversarial because it can't think. So you can always derail it.

lelanthran • today at 10:01 AM

> Why must there be a dichotomy: "use AI/don't think for yourself", vs "don't use AI/think for yourself"?

It doesn't have to be any extreme, although your next statement:

> I think we'll need to grow in our individual relationship with AI.

makes me think that anyone who develops a relationship with a tool is probably on one end of that extreme already.

➕ show 2 replies
noir_lord • today at 9:00 AM

It’s a matrix of numbers not a friend.

Strangely I’m not friends with my toaster either.

➕ show 5 replies
pandemic_region • today at 9:01 AM

I would label AI as friend in the same way I would label ads as informative.

➕ show 1 reply