logoalt Hacker News

amiantos • today at 9:06 AM • 5 replies • view on HN

The thing is that people who like AI have been successfully "othered" so thoroughly that no one cares that the internet has become an unwelcoming and often downright hostile place to hang out for us. Every day there is some new essay about how the thing we like is actually super bad and we shouldn't like it. There's some new argument about how people who use AI are actually massive dumbasses who can't think for themselves anymore, or how people who use AI to make art aren't actually being creative and are only contributing the global warming and water shortages. No one cares about what that does to our mental health, because we're "others". We're evil, we're shilling for corporations, we're trying to destroy art and culture.

"Hey, I wrote this useful app and thought I'd share it." "No you didn't write it, AI wrote it, you did nothing." "Okay, sorry, well I built it with the help of AI." "No you didn't build it, AI built it, you did nothing." "Well, I came up with the idea and I worked with AI to bring it into the world, is that better?" "Cool story, bro, how much water did you waste on the AI you used for that? Don't you care that you're destroying the environment just to make your little toy?"

I've realized, probably similar to you, that the scales are extremely imbalanced, and it's making us respond with the same hostility finally. If people want to go on the internet and write essays about how AI is terrible and the people who use it are also terrible, then it should be just as acceptable for us to go on the internet and mock, ridicule, and insult the people who are against it. But, yeah, it isn't. If we get angry, we're the problem. It's not that we're having a totally reasonable reaction to a completely unreasonable cultural moment where cruelty is celebrated so long as you believe you've got the moral upper hand.

We're just expected to swallow it, getting chased out or banned from online spaces and communities we used to feel welcome in. I spent a decade making open source software and giving it away for free, but now if someone sees that I'm using AI as part of my hobby, I get insulted and ridiculed. I've been places that have Code of Conducts that say everyone should be welcoming, where I am promptly bullied and called incompetent for my AI usage (:waves at #ircv3 on libera:) and no one does a thing about it. Because I'm an "other" now, for using AI, the rules are not meant to protect me or you anymore.

It's pretty gross and someday all these people will hopefully look back on this time and feel disappointed in themselves for so quickly turning on their fellow humans, just so they can feel superior for some reason or another. Every day they likely flush gallons and gallons of fresh water down the drain on showers and who knows what else, but the person who uses AI for any reason is the real problem. Time to write another essay about how people who use AI have no critical thinking skills and how I'm so superior for not wanting to use AI! Hopefully I don't break my arms patting myself on the back too hard.


Replies

Planktonne • today at 12:05 PM

> The thing is that people who like AI have been successfully "othered" so thoroughly that no one cares that the internet has become an unwelcoming and often downright hostile place to hang out for us.

This is an entirely predictable backlash to bad behaviour from pro-AI spammers. If that doesn't describe you, then I'm sorry, but just about every community online is having to deal with a massive influx of spam and hate from people who say they're 'pro-AI' and use that as a shield for bad behaviour.

> We're evil, we're shilling for corporations, we're trying to destroy art and culture.

It's not nice to hear it, but a lot of the time this is true for a lot of the most visible pro-AI people. If you want the backlash to stop, then there need to be both more positive examples of pro-AI people, and far fewer negative ones.

RightHN • today at 10:38 AM

The training of LLMs is the single most egregious theft in human history. The creative works of humanity have been ingested without permission or remuneration to train these LLMs, and now what they stole is being sold to enrich a handful of tech companies and their billionaire C-suite. People have already and will continue to lose their livelihoods because of this technology. That's before any environmental impacts are even considered.

> It's pretty gross and someday all these people will hopefully look back on this time and feel disappointed in themselves for so quickly turning on their fellow humans

Yes, I couldn't have said it better myself.

AIShill101 • today at 9:42 AM

Yea man true, lately I've been feeling the same on any online community I visit. Heck I lurked around here since forever but I made this account cuz your comment resonates with me.

It does a number on you to not have a community anymore just because of AI. I'm on libera(6 yo acc) and fluxer recently and all I get is hate for mentioning or even trying to recommend a tool that might be made with AI. Sucks. Communities change so fast.

stereolambda • today at 11:08 AM

Answering as a mild AI skeptic who doesn't buy into all the talking points. I myself see some measurable benefit but also lots of cognitive and organizational rot that IMO the hyperscale LLM tech itself doesn't have the potential to really outweigh. This is just for context.

For the show HN type stuff, here's the other perspective. It used to be that I could use these showcases to study and learn for my own projects. To see how you work. Nowadays not so much, I don't see your work with agents, and probably it wouldn't be that interesting anyway.

Another point, the better projects felt like pushing forward the human achievement somehow. Nowadays it's more like showing your so-so drawing to your mom or Reddit. Yeah, it feels good to praise (not saying it's bad) but that's it. Lots of people could do it. The only thing that remains is that maybe your project is singularly useful to me. But let's be honest, that is rare with software.

As for your complaint that people are rude and hostile, I hear you in the sense that this probably contributed to the success of LLMs massively. If people would "just" communicate effectively and helpfully, we could avoid much of the use of chatbots. But that isn't new. Also, of course people have the right to disagree and dislike but this is often turning into being rude on the internet.

And worth realizing that being officially "welcoming" for more than a decade has been smelling of a code for unwelcoming and social paranoia. Now opposition to AI has been somehow added to that zeitgeist and fervor. It's funny that I can imagine it going the opposite way, had maybe the early 2010s AI bros been more politically savvy or some social conversation circumstances going differently. Then you would be hunted down for not loving AI enough.

suddenlybananas • today at 9:22 AM

Wow I feel so bad for you! It must be really hard being persecuted for willingly using a trillion dollar company's products and forcing the result down other people's throats.