logoalt Hacker News

cadamsdotcom • today at 10:38 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

It's an oversimplification to equate the leveraging of external intelligence with not thinking for yourself.

External intelligence will get you out of a ton of intellectual grunt work so you are freed to think at a higher level. You've are freed to think about different things more core to your problem, and if you wield the tools well you can choose what you offload. But it should be viewed as a tool not a shortcut...

Consider an accountant summing numbers with a calculator vs. by hand. There's way less thinking needed to get the numbers summed right. But blindly summing numbers doesn't make the work correct even if the sums are correct...

No one should put their name on work they didn't proofread, or if they shipped whatever the model pooped out on its first go. That is not your work yet. That's what we have to instil. It is OK to draft with AI! Leverage tools, sure - but know the material, make your work your own, and don't ship your first draft.


Replies

FinnLobsien • today at 10:43 AM

> Consider an accountant summing numbers with a calculator vs. by hand. There's way less thinking needed to get the numbers summed right. But blindly summing numbers doesn't make the work correct even if the sums are correct...

Yes, correct. The problem is what happens when someone doesn't know what summing even is or what numbers go into the calculation and why something should be summed.

Yet that's exactly what many are doing now. I agree that we can let AI handle some grunt work. I think a good differentiator is this:

-Doing entire research papers with AI defeats the point because so much of the intellectual benefit comes from the writing process.

-Once you've deeply thought through everything, it's justifiable to automate writing a ton of repetitive, slightly customized grant applications.