logoalt Hacker News

ForgotMyUUID • today at 11:30 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

Take it as a compliment, of course! Reading a generated text feels like a wiping a spit on one's face. One day sending an LLM-generated text will become a mauvais ton again.

> Assignment documents that start with "you are strongly encouraged to explore the use of AI" which quickly turns into the clear understanding that you aren't just encouraged but expected to use it. LLM is not an AI. IBM Watson is an AI, Prolog is AI, OWL ontologies, expert systems etc - technically any system where knowledge is encoded explicitly and unambiguously. Language model is an advanced vectorized search engine, a compression algorithm with a human-like dialogue system on top. LLM has no intelligence. Here is a simple gedanken proof of that: if we define an LLM as a "rational" system the latter means that it does not contradict itself, it has a complete non-contradicting picture of the world. We train an LLM on the whole literal corpus of humanity completely ignoring the fact that the progress is , in matter, a resolving contradictions. Having all books of humanity on the table is necessary but not sufficient for building a real intelligent system. Building such a system would imply identifying and resolving all of the contradictions, all the ignorance present in our knowledge. Calling an LLM an AI is the greatest misleading marketing trick in history.

I do voluntary teaching while working as an engineer at my job. I teach the interns because this is how I learned my skills. Except math and physics, 90% of skills I learned at the work place from elder colleagues. We have to surround ourselves with knowledgeable people who are able to take responsibility. Even if they will not stay in your company. I can't just sit still while this tech is destroying our and our children's future for the sake of smb's short-term profit. One might get all of the money of the world, but some things cannot be bought.