logoalt Hacker News

sho • yesterday at 3:03 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Your ideas about the tropopause are a bit eccentric. 36kft is just a model average, it's more like 25kft at the poles and 50-60kft at the equator. Large jetliners fly well below and above it all the time.

Temperature's just one factor. Air density, lift-to-drag ratio, weight, speed and engine performance all matter. Thinner air reduces drag, but you still need to generate enough lift, and there's a point beyond which the trade-off stops paying off. Business jets are generally lighter, with wings and engines designed for higher-altitude cruising, and regularly fly above 40kft, sometimes even 50kft.

The general max service height of airliners is an engineering trade-off between air density, lift-to-drag, weight, speed and engine efficiency. Air temp is part of it, but a small part, and there's nothing magical about the tropopause.


Replies

ajross • yesterday at 4:20 PM

Shrug, this is the middle of the bell curve argument. The Jedi and I are off at the ends repeating "Jets fly at the FL360 tropopause and have since they were invented".

Though I'll allow myself one bit of pedantry:

> Business jets are generally lighter, with wings and engines designed for higher-altitude cruising, and regularly fly above 40kft, sometimes even 50kft.

This is wrong. Bizjets fly high because their passengers like it and because they can get places faster. They fly more efficiently at the tropopause for the same reason jetliners do. There's no design difference other than flying "more empty" with more available thrust.