logoalt Hacker News

FunkyMushroom • yesterday at 3:15 PM • 14 replies • view on HN

The related economic concept here is the Broken Window Fallacy. Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy, because there's an opportunity cost doing to anything. And replacing the need to "fix broken windows" or do now-AI-automated work would free up that opportunity cost. Which is how it's worked for nearly all automation. (Though Computers are subject to long running debate about this. See the Solow Productivity Paradox)

The gigawatt-sized asterisk on all of this is that AI companies have to capture that $1 billion. Anthropic has to ten-fold increase it's revenues or it goes bankrupt under it's current commitments. It has to increase it's revenues another 10 times to reach the $10,000,000,000,000/yr revenue required to support it's current valuation.

Anthropic put their Total Addressable Market at 35% of Global GDP (~$40 trillion/yr). They're planning to capture all of the money.

The second gigawatt-sized asterisk is that because of the fine handiwork of Mr. Huang, China has made very competitive AI models available for free, so the actual ability for AI companies to capture the value of the labour they displace ends up being quite limited. Thus a problem in the predictions: Something as to break, but it is as of yet unclear what that will be. Maybe Chinese AI will be banned, maybe Anthropic & OpenAI go bankrupt.


Replies

benrutter • today at 9:09 AM

> Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy, because there's an opportunity cost doing to anything

I know this is only a small bit of your overall point, but I don't think this is an accepted fact of economics.

The "opportunity" cost is true is you're comparing redundant work to productive work, but OP was comparing to unemployment, which is a different case. A bit of a simplification, but less employment leads to less spending which leads to less money to companies etc.

Here's a nice quote from Keynes about redundant work:

> If the Treasury were to fill old bottles with bank-notes, bury them at suitable depths in disused coal-mines which are then filled up to the surface with town rubbish, and leave it to private enterprise on well-tried principles of laissez-faire to dig the notes up again (the right to do so being obtained, of course, by tendering for leases of the note-bearing territory), there need be no more unemployment and, with the help of repercussions, the real income of the community, and its capital wealth, would probably become a good deal greater than it actually is.

cogman10 • yesterday at 5:31 PM

The big issue with all this is that people whose jobs are destroyed by automation very rarely end up seeing improvements to their standard of living. And with the modern system, people are pretty boned if they chose the wrong career.

The luddite movement is informative here. When manufactures found ways to mass produce goods eliminating jobs left and right, the people in the skilled trades whose jobs were eliminated did not benefit in the slightest from the economic progress.

We now live in an era of diminishing jobs which provide livable wages. It's why so many economies have moved to require everyone to participate in the labor market just to achieve the basics.

Put more simply, broken windows harm society as a whole, but they do make glazers and the people who support the glazers happy. Now that we live in an era where a significant portion of the population is glazers so-to-speak and ai threatens to eliminate those jobs, it looks like the only path forward for those glazers is low wage jobs.

➕ show 3 replies
cowlevel • today at 8:04 AM

What if the opportunity cost is zero because all useful work is being done?

lelanthran • yesterday at 3:26 PM

> Maybe Chinese AI will be banned, maybe Anthropic & OpenAI go bankrupt.

Unless the entire world bans it, how would that help?

➕ show 4 replies
blobbers • yesterday at 4:48 PM

Sorry can you clarify the 10T revenue part? Apple makes about 0.5T revenue and has 5X the valuation. Pricing on revenue multiple you’d say anthropic needs 100B in revenue, which at 16B last quarter isn’t too far fetched.

➕ show 3 replies
raducu • yesterday at 3:30 PM

> Broken Window Fallacy. Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy.

The problem with AI is that work on an unprecedented scale will be made redundant and economic power will be concentrated into the hands of very few and there will be no way out in perpetuity.

➕ show 4 replies
SoftTalker • yesterday at 4:55 PM

> China has made very competitive AI models available for free,

Is this a "commoditize your competitors" strategy when your motive isn't profit but disruption?

➕ show 1 reply
smallmancontrov • yesterday at 4:07 PM

The Broken Window "Fallacy" assumes that distributional problems don't exist, lol.

I know why rich people who own many shares of aggregate economic capacity want me to believe that it is the only important thing and that sacrificing aggregate capacity to fix distributional problems is never worthwhile. But I don't believe it. The industrial revolution was gnarly with unnecessary distribution problems that ensured crippling poverty for the masses amid extraordinary leaps in aggregate capacity. This time around I don't want a century of Cyberpunk Oliver Twist before the peons are allowed a dignified life.

Adjacent, improved argument: taxes are a better fix for distributional problems than throwing stones at windows. I agree, and I will add that broken windows are a better fix for distributional problems than guillotines. I really really hope that we can convince capital to pay taxes because that's the only future where things don't go to monumental shit before getting better.

➕ show 2 replies
Haven880 • yesterday at 11:32 PM

Anthropic assume Deepseek, Kimi, Qwen, Tencent don't exist and OpenAI is shrinking. Reminds me of Elon laughing at BYD decade ago. What will happen, USA get boxed in while surrounding countries trade with China. You can just look at 2 items USA was champion off for nearly 100 years: cars production and energy production. China is like the replicators in Stargate, they just peoduce more and more...and cheaper too. Heck even data centers, China now completed way more than what US able to this year. And they now start building EUV machine after their manhattan-like project euv prototype succeeded a couple months back. In 2029 they will have a woman on moon. Meanwhile I am still waiting Elon (not NASA) to do it.

➕ show 1 reply
retwakm4 • yesterday at 4:20 PM

I am a big believer in the solow paradox and I don't think AI changes anything about it. Just more money down the tubes.

Go read the papers on it if you want to hear some of the immensely plausible theories as to why micros and the internet and all sorts of what we think is technological innovation doesn't show up in economic productivity data.

233mhz • yesterday at 3:52 PM

> Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy

Are we talking about the real economy or the stock market casino? I have a feeling one doesn't care about facts and logic

0c3ca83 • yesterday at 3:42 PM

> Anthropic put their Total Addressable Market at 35% of Global GDP (~$40 trillion/yr). They're planning to capture all of the money

Oh, goody. They left room for their friends, Google and OpenAI.

➕ show 1 reply
joedwin • today at 6:06 AM

[flagged]

noncoml • yesterday at 5:04 PM

[flagged]