logoalt Hacker News

Wowfunhappy • yesterday at 3:51 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> The usual way for proving it is to say: [...]

I've always found this alternate way more intuitive:

⅓ = 0.333...

⅓ × 3 = 1

0.333... × 3 = 0.999...

I've been able to use this method to convince fifth graders who had limited algebra experience. (Instead of ×3, I used ⅓ + ⅓ + ⅓. The fifth graders knew multiplication but using addition made it slightly clearer, I thought.)


Replies

uptrails • yesterday at 4:09 PM

Neither of these are much of a proof, though. They're appeals to intuition that, in this instance, turn out to be correct. There are other appeals to intuition with infinite sequences / series that turn out to be dead wrong, so I feel that this is teaching the wrong thing.

➕ show 2 replies