To take it in a different direction, Arrigo Sacchi (one of the more legendary managers of AC Milan), who had no professional sporting background, when questioned about his qualifications said "I never realised that in order to become a jockey you have to have been a horse first."
It would probably help a lot, given how badly animals are treated. But yeah his point is right, it's not a strict necessity for the job.
The analogy with football players/managers was in my head too — there are many average professional footballers that go on to become fantastic managers and there are lots of exceptionally talented footballers that make terrible managers.