logoalt Hacker News

dust-jacket • today at 4:36 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

The analogy here is pretty ropey IMO.

Yes, a guitar player should not expect to just stop playing guitar because they're good enough but equally... a composer does not need to be able to play each of the instruments they compose for.


Replies

ctkhn • today at 4:38 PM

Composing and playing are totally different. The better comparison is stopping composing because they've got good enough, not stopping playing the instruments they compose for.

➕ show 1 reply
mariusor • today at 4:40 PM

Yes, but a composer that forgets what fingerings are possible for a guitar player with human hands might introduce a fingering that can't be played by them.