logoalt Hacker News

thih9 • yesterday at 4:39 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> There are other appeals to intuition with infinite sequences / series that turn out to be dead wrong

Could you give an example? This sounds interesting, both in context and on its own.


Replies

bhattid • today at 4:08 AM

https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/12906/the-staircase...

I would say this is a good example where it's geometrically "proven" that pi = 4. It's convincing enough where if someone didn't already learn the value of pi, I might expect them to believe this proof.

The idea is that if you circumscribe a square around a unit circle and take its perimeter, you obtain 4. If you "invert" the corners of the square until they hit the circle, the perimeter remains unchanged. If you iterate infinitely, the sequence of polygons eventually converges to the circle.

In this case, the sequence truly does converge to a circle. However, the subtle detail is that, in the limit, this manner of measuring perimeter is the taxicab metric (and NOT the Euclidean metric), where pi actually does equal 4. It's not so obvious geometrically, but it shows that there's a distinction between a sequence of curves and the corresponding sequence of lengths.

EDIT: Though, having said all this, I feel the proof given about 0.999... equaling 1 is rigorous, but I suppose there's some subjectivity involved.