logoalt Hacker News

rathboma • today at 4:46 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

I've been using a Framework 13 AMD for three years. I use Linux full time, so seemed like a sensible choice.

It's been...fine. The hardware itself has held up and feels plenty fast, but I get duplicate key presses on the keyboard sporadically, and the standby battery life is absolutely terrible. Like 5x worse than my 10 year old ThinkPad that uses bios-level s3 sleep.

It's so bad that even if I charged the laptop last night, I won't go to a coffee shop in the morning without a charger. I've debugged it as far as possible. I think this is the expected power drain.

Echoing similar sentiments in here - I want to be able to wholeheartedly recommend it, but can't yet - and I haven't had to deal with support.

Maybe the new pro models are better? I suspect none will be better with standby battery life with s0 sleep.


Replies

ggreer • today at 6:08 PM

Yeah, suspend to idle (S0ix) wakes up the quickest, but uses the most power. It tends to completely drain the battery on my Thinkpad X1 Carbon within 36 hours. When I got my Framework 13, I made sure it used hybrid sleep. Hybrid sleep suspends to idle, then wakes up every hour to check the battery state. If the battery gets down to 5% or it's been more than 2 hours since the laptop was initially suspended, it saves RAM state to disk and powers off completely. So you get quick resume if you use the laptop with in an hour or two, but you also avoid draining the battery if you leave it sitting around for days. This behavior is pretty similar to how Macs work.

The Arch wiki has some useful info about how to get this behavior.[1] It's enabled by default on Omarchy.[2]

1. https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Power_management/Suspend_an...

2. https://omarchy.org/manual/system-sleep/

ffemac • today at 5:03 PM

Thinkpads are so much better. Nice repairable hardware, and great Linux support. (I own both Thinkpads and Framework hardware. it's not hard to tell)

monomania • today at 4:53 PM

I've got an early F13P (AMD). I'm happy with it overall, but if I put it on standby overnight it loses ~20% charge. Before I put Linux on it, I configured the BIOS to never charge past 80%, and I don't think I've gotten it below 20% more than once or twice, so it's been treated pretty well (it's also less than a year old...).