Macbook keyboards might not be outright faulty anymore, but they still kinda suck. Over the past ~year I've used a 6 year old Microsoft Surface laptop, a brand new M5 Macbook Pro, and a ~4 year old HP, and enjoy the Macbook's keyboard by far the least of the bunch.
ultra-low-travel-distance keyboards are an acquired taste, but I think using them exclusively for long enough has caused my opinions to flip to thinking all keyboards (even desktop ones) should be made more like them