logoalt Hacker News

breakwaterlabs • today at 4:56 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

A chargeback burns every bridge, and will ultimately get denied if the company provided the good in return for the money. If you start talking about consumer protection laws, the credit company will tell you that this is a matter for civil courts; their "jurisdiction" is just ensuring that charges were authorized and the goods or services were provided.

It is somewhat unfortunate that "chargebacks", like "talk to the manager", have become cheatcodes because their genuine utility has gotten drowned out by a flood of mis/ab-use.


Replies

joshuat • today at 6:50 PM

My experience with chargebacks is rather limited, and always through Amex, but when I received a product that did not work as expected/advertised and their support team denied a refund/replacement Amex was more than happy to give me my money back.

I'm sure there is misuse but if the good you receive in return for the money is non-functional, I think a chargeback is the appropriate step if support decides they aren't interested in fixing the problem themselves.

nortlov • today at 6:17 PM

Sounds like OP doesn't care to maintain the bridge with Framework.

Sure, chargebacks can be abused but what about OP suggests that’s happening here? They spent over three months troubleshooting, exchanged thirty support emails, supplied photos, videos and reproducible diagnostics, tried replacement parts, and sent the laptop to Framework's repair center. They also explicitly asked for replacement parts or a refund back months ago.

➕ show 1 reply
cestith • today at 6:32 PM

In some places the consumer protection or fairness in markets laws require that what is sold doesn't just physically exist, but that it arrives to the customer in a suitable state sufficient for the use for which it was sold. It's a crazy idea, I know.