logoalt Hacker News

wing-_-nuts • yesterday at 5:29 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

No, but when AI companies insist they need to build out more datacenters to make better AI, we, as a society are well within our rights to ask if their goals would actually be a net good for society.

These people are literally saying their product is dangerous, and that it will eventually put a large portion of the population out of work. Until we change our economic system so that "people are entitled to a decent quality of life" err sorry, 'free stuff' in your words, even without work, don't think the voting public is just gonna stand by and let them do it.

It's rather callous, bad faith framing to say 'you're not entitled to free stuff' when that 'free stuff' is the very things they need to live, and you've destroyed their ability to acquire it through work.


Replies

alex43578 • yesterday at 7:24 PM

The voting public is always free to make choices, including those that go on to hurt society (see the expansion of the welfare state, the ballooning debt, and forever-war, or in this case seeking to cripple technological progress). It doesn't mean they're right.

Also, nobody has "destroyed their ability to acquire it" - the market has set the price and they have to adapt. If I create terrible paintings, I shouldn't still be entitled to millions because someone else's paintings sold at auction.

Members of the voting public should also be free to call out a system that has a meaningful voting bloc (20 to 47% depending on how you want to slice it) who consistently vote for more free stuff, while contributing nothing to the system. A system where everyone takes and nobody makes is not a net good for society.

➕ show 2 replies