logoalt Hacker News

CamperBob2 • yesterday at 8:48 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

(a) The stuff they 'strip-mined' is still there;

(b) It benefits everyone who can afford a $20/month subscription.


Replies

steve_adams_86 • yesterday at 9:23 PM

(a) Kind of; aren't they buying and destroying incredible numbers of books at an alarming pace?

You could say the data from the books still exists (digitally) but no one can access it other than them, now.

Not to say we'd easily access most of it either, but that does still seem subtractive to me.

➕ show 1 reply
emaro • today at 6:41 AM

re (b): in absolute terms, yes. But does it hold in relative terms as well? How are you going to compete with your $20 plan with people who can affort the $200 plan or with OAI/ANT internals who are buring $1000s/day and have access to unreleased models? In comparsion, you're worse off than before.

It's the same with wages: yes, they've gone up, so you should be better off. But most people loose anyway because a) costs have increased more than their salary and b) wealth concentration increased as well, so in comparsion they're also not better off.

LastTrain • yesterday at 9:26 PM

(a) yes and (b) yes the masses pay 20 a month to the few. that is what I was talking about.

➕ show 1 reply
Choad_20261104 • yesterday at 10:13 PM

back a decade ago, when i was studying LLMs and generative models the only way to get a foothold was to 'give away' your expertise in public forums like github. When Microsoft bought it, I was certain I would never practice there and it hurt me because that was the ONLY way anyone's expertise was legitimized.

Without github evidence, you couldn't get a word in.

I was hosed because I was selfish with my intellect. the world's biggest self-pwn

serves me right that I didn't get a job in the industry, and missed out on all that dough, doesn't it?

the direction hasn't changed. Its going the same way and you should think twice about subscribing especially when once you ask anything, - i assume - the provider is obliged to scrub the request for safety concerns, and log it and keep an archive, and casually absorb it....

and in the mean time - if I understand the nature of the world correctly - anything you ask/submit actually no longer belongs to you. [q.v. FBook T&Cs]

there is no privacy in your queries and there will be no guarantee that what you may have ASSUMED would be a unique innovative idea all your own is now for all in the hands of a much smarter thing that has a lot better access to resources and countervailing data it may decide not to tell you about.

this doom has been ongoing for a long time. its bad, and we should start to figure the least bad outcomes and work toward those first