logoalt Hacker News

uptrails • yesterday at 11:57 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> NVIDIA's bosses sex scandal is somehow making NVDA trade at 10x its PE while growing 60% YoY, while Costco trades at 40x PE at a 5% growth rate.

How does this support your argument? I think it tells us the opposite. Nvidia's growth is short-lived and its future is uncertain - it hinges on AI spending and data center buildout continuing at the same rate, and none of the major customers being successful in developing their own chips (all are trying). Their financing deals also increase their exposure to macro shifts. Investors are (righly) pricing in that uncertainty.

In contrast, Costco is a relatively boring business, but if you invest in it, you're unlikely to lose a whole lot of money very suddenly, so a decade or two of boring growth is priced in. I assume you're cranky about your NVDA stock dropping, but fundamentals go beyond a snapshot in time.


Replies

anon291 • today at 12:25 AM

Why is the growth uncertain? Previously NVDA made GPUs, which were for gaming. Today they make what is quickly becoming general-purpose processors a la Intel. This changes the market significantly and like Intel, turns NVDA from a specialized component manufacturer into a key computing component.

Whereas the GPU market attracted barely any competition; today there are at least 2 dozen startups attempting to slice NVIDIAs market. Several of these competitors are now themselves public (Cerebras). These are real indicators that the market expects real growth.

> I assume you're cranky about your NVDA stock dropping, but fundamentals go beyond a snapshot in time.

NVDA is reaching the point where they can take the company private with a fairly typical bank loan, while returning significant returns to investors. If the share price goes into double digits, it would be possible for a small group of investors to buy the entire thing. This is frankly ridiculous to think that NVDA is fairly valued at the present movement. My NVDA holdings are actually quite small relatively speaking, but the idea the stock is fairly valued is ridiculous. I've been buying more obviously.

➕ show 3 replies