logoalt Hacker News

slibhb • today at 12:56 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

Claude is not solving Riemann without human involvement. It's a tool, an amazing one, but still a tool.

"Reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions, and can never pretend to any other office than to serve and obey them." Claude doesn't have passions; man does. Relax!


Replies

bemtevi • today at 12:58 AM

Man has passions when they can be put towards something that others find significant. And a tool is never just a tool; it suggests new directions and initiates the growth of technology on the medium of our desires, and manipulates us as much as we manipuate it; the degree to which this happens is proportional to the power and possibilites of the tool.

dadadad100 • today at 1:08 AM

So if a student hands in a Claude essay she can say she wrote it with a tool? Credit to Partially Examined Life for that argument.