logoalt Hacker News

weitendorf • today at 9:05 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

It's really difficult to explain macroeconomics to people because the average person:

1. Thinks the economy is the money in it rather than the value it represents

2. Doesn't understand that the economy is not zero sum. Money is zero sum, but we can make more or less as needed. Wealth and spending power are very much positive sum

3. The economy doesn't provide anything except a way to match supply to demand. That includes the labor market, actually as the one more privileged than any other in terms of economic policy. "Jobs" are where supply of labor meets demand for work.

   The economy doesn't "lose" jobs; supply and demand for labor change, so jobs come back when they meet again. When someone loses a job; eventually it becomes a good deal for someone to pay for it again (perhaps at a different or better price), or a better deal to take a different job, because their labor remains valauble.
4. We can always increase the demand for work by giving people more money to spend on the same amount of goods/services they already consume. Employers respond by hiring additional employees because they only have so much buffer to raise production or output without more people. A fixed amount of capital can only produce so much. Eventually it's just more profitable to hire people.

5. When an industry gets disrupted, that doesn't mean the disruptor destroyed the value the product provided or the employees' labor. The value was what the product did for the buyers, which they probably do better.

  And your labor is possibly even more valuable if you can use it to produce more valuable things like your competitor did, or if new firms are able to form that better provide what people want in the current economy. This is actually relatively common, see eg. the dotcom bubble.
6. You can't just assume every person will be positively or negatively impacted by change in the same way. And there is no guarantee a certain kind of job or labor will maintain the same value forever.

  But as long as you can do something that helps another person, and are employable, macroeconomic/government policy can stimulate demand until someone wants to hire you for something.
7. AI can't soak up all demand for everything because the underlying capital is constrained and can only grow so fast. Once those become bottlenecks, that means lots of demand for jobs that help grow that.

We can create infinite demand. Think about everything that's been created in your lifetime. When in doubt, follow the incremental demand - there is money and work to do there.