logoalt Hacker News

orbital-decay • today at 10:58 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

Biomechanically and due to how the nervous system works, the fastest and most precise movements can only be done with full arm movement and fingers for extra accuracy, on a device which is the most reactive (e.g. zero weight/static friction/hysteresis/dead zones) and has a very specific movement resistance (e.g. dynamic friction), low enough but not too low. Many control schemes have been tried over decades but these basic rules seem to give the best results. Which only leaves the scheme most skilled FPS players already prefer: a basic, most lightweight mouse with a properly centered sensor, held with something close to a claw grip, without too many buttons that would mess up your aiming. Plus a keyboard under the other hand, it's a lot less important than the mouse.

Casual FPS play is more forgiving, e.g. gyro seems to work for many people as well (full arm + precise movement again, but not ideally reactive/resistant). But you can't put too many buttons on such a controller either.