I'll take the other side of that bet. I'm against the Great Man theory of history. Jobs, Bezos, Gates, Huang - the companies they started are now much more than the founders themselves.
Most companies go downhill, or at least become ordinary once the founfers leave. It's not necessarily about skill, but rather that founders care in a different way about the products, while later people in charge care more about the short-term bottom line.
A great leader alone can't achieve much. He needs luck and skills to surround himself with good and skilled men.
A mediocre leader surrounded even with many great men, will still produce shit. Might take awhile depending on momentum, but will happen.
Founder mode is always better regardless how big the company has grown.
Jobs did it twice. Musk has done it two or three times, depending on whether you feel Tesla counts, given that he didn't start it.
Apple without Jobs (pt 1) was a trainwreck.
Apple without Jobs (pt 2) is just mediocre.
Msft without Gates (Ballmer) enough said.
Amazon without Bezos too early to tell (but cracks are starting to show)
> I'm against the Great Man theory of history. Jobs, Bezos, Gates, Huang - the companies they started are now much more than the founders themselves.
If the Great Man theory of history wasn't true, then Europe would have a bunch of successful tech companies, because founders would pop up randomly out of the large not-wanting-to-move-to-America population there.
The odds of any startup being successful are pretty low, so it's certainly notable when the same founder has multiple successes such as Jobs Apple (x2), Next and Pixar, especially when the personality/traits of the person seems directly related to the success.
Much as I dislike him, bit I think Musk also deserves credit for his serial successes, even if most of that is more in motivating others who work for him, and being willing to put his considerable personal wealth on the line.