For all his faults regarding his control of his delinquent member, coupled with the obvious export smuggling ring, and now perhaps accounting fraud (new SEC investigation, may end up being just a rumor) I did appreciate that Huang was sensible in the sense that:
1. Didn't pearl clutch or make every issue around Silicon Valley an "AI issue". A lot of drivel commentary and political mileage can be had by just demonizing AI. He was rather sensible versus the pervasive hyperventilating and in my view, self-serving (oss models getting too good) talk coming out of other leaders in the space.
2. Didn't treat China as the enemy. Said openly it's good for the world if China uses AI to solve cancer, etc.
Obviously in retrospect maybe he sort of overindexed on #2. But on the flip side, it doesn't seem the US government actually wants to confront China. They essentially let this export smuggling slide and knew about the spy.
Are they alone? No Americans I know want to fight China. What throng of Americans is relishing annihilation in Taiwan? We can't even subdue one of the most backward, poorest nations on the entire globe. Americans want to follow up Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran with China?
So really, in a world of madness Huang felt quite sensible. No AI isn't going to by necessity kill us all. No we don't have to think of this as a zero sum competition with China. We can try to be sensible about this.
Then it turned out he was fucking a spy and multiple other women who were not his wife. He fell for the oldest trick in the book. Sad someone who seemed so sensible will forever be famous for being so exposed as a fool.
I am still struck that his two general points were more or less correct. But indeed it is not good now to be associated with ideas he championed. Perhaps this was the greatest success of this whole ordeal, if one takes the manner of his rise and fall to not be wholly unrelated to some species of sabotage.