logoalt Hacker News

bonoboTP • today at 7:15 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I'm very disappointed in the Debbie downer bitter reaction online, trying to grasp at straws to somehow make this achievement look bad. Reminds me how different people are in real life and spending time online is more and more a waste. Also some of these may be bots farming engagement with this sentiment.


Replies

jrflo • today at 8:19 PM

I think on HN at least it's mostly cope. Many people are scared of how this will disrupt their lives/livelihoods and want to come up with an excuse to make it "not real".

FranzFerdiNaN • today at 8:00 PM

I find it a bit hilarious. People are basically throwing the entire field of math under the bus in their attempt to hate this result. I've seen people claim that Lean is basically just Python and can be used to proof anything, that formally verifying math means nothing, or that this was a waste of resources as the result cant be used to do anything useful immediately. Anything but accepting the possibility that the proof might be real and/or that LLMs can be used for something significant like this.

And just now i saw someone posting that Lean is actually a piece of shit software that isnt academic and just AI slop.