logoalt Hacker News

LogicFailsMe • today at 7:45 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

But he didn't break the law as far as we can tell. Obeyed its letter whilst violating its spirit, probably, but that's not breaking the law. Nvidia has impeccable lawyers for this I'm sure.

Are you good with Elon Musk spending $444M to buy a state or cutting off Starlink to Ukraine? Neither of those were illegal either. I'm curious where the bar really lands.

And yes, moral relativism. Seems to be a best practice here now given the results of the 2024 election.


Replies

otterley • today at 8:34 PM

The most likely reason he was fired is that the company’s lawyers and Board think he broke the law, and their job is to protect the company. To continue to employ him after they came to believe he broke the law could make the penalties even worse. They won’t come outright and say so, of course, as that would violate attorney-client privilege.

You’re not an insider, and are not in possession of all the facts. (Admittedly, I’m not either, but as an attorney, I can put the pieces together.) The insiders know much more than either the press or the government. That said, there are plenty of factual and legal analyses out there that, if true, give the Government plenty of fodder to indict, if not convict, Nvidia and Huang himself.

Besides, why do you (or really, anyone here) care whether Jensen Huang got fired? What impact does it have on your life?

qaq • today at 8:39 PM

I'm not sure how you've concluded that throttling Starshield was legal. We're talking about a US defense contractor restricting critical military communications infra. And if any of this was coordinated with Russia, that opens up a whole different set of potential legal issues

➕ show 1 reply