logoalt Hacker News

alethic • today at 8:18 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I think it is an irresponsible lack of context to not cite the proof that has been in progress internally in the mathematics community, however, even if just as a footnote. Anthropic's proof is a slop nuke. A mechanization of Masullo's proof and its surrounding work seems of more practical importance with regards to making idiomatic and reusable formal mathematics than proof-mining Anthropic's proof. Furthermore, I think it's simply insulting not to discuss the work of the mathematical community that both proofs have built upon here...


Replies

TwoFx • today at 8:51 PM

There are efforts to mechanize Masullo's proof [1]. As of right now, this work is ongoing, so there is nothing to report yet.

With people being as confused as they are (just look at the messages in this thread), I think it's good that TFA is very clear about what it is saying, namely that a specific formal artifact that was posted to the internet is correct, and nothing else. Making value judgements or contrasting the proofs (or proof attempts) is not the point of the post.

(I work at the Lean FRO, but I wasn't involved in the verification effort or the writing of the post)

[1]: https://leanprover.zulipchat.com/#narrow/channel/113488-gene...

➕ show 1 reply