logoalt Hacker News

franticgecko3 • today at 8:47 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I postulate: "there is no machine that can produce brass springs".

A party interested in proving me wrong wheels in a machine draped in a cloth. They reach under the cloth to turn it on. It whirs and a short while later ejects a brass spring.

No matter what kind of machine is under the cloth, my theory has been proven false. I should reveal the machine under the cloth only if I'm interested in knowing how the machine works, but either way there is clearly a machine that can produce brass springs.

Now we have a sequence of Lean statements that satisfies the Riemann hypothesis, the fact that you can do it at all is the part we're interested in, and it's the part that proves it. If you want to know why, you can read all 17 million lines.


Replies

bwestergard • today at 8:57 PM

It's more like there are two machines under cloths: one that generates an object, and another that determines whether it is a brass spring. If I don't know how the second (brass spring detecting) machine works, telling me that it detected a brass spring doesn't convince me that the first machine in fact produced a brass spring.