logoalt Hacker News

gerdesj • today at 12:33 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

Thank you for providing a properly nuanced interpretation.

The thing about population trends judged via DNA sampling is that they happen over quite long timelines.

A similar topic, closer to my home (England, UK) is the "viking invasion", and the "Saxon invasion". It's quite simply not that ... simple. There was no invasion per se. Over a few centuries quite a few people rocked up on these shores from elsewhere and settled or violently stole stuff or both.

That was after an actual invasion - Julius Caesar in 55 and 54BC and eventually Claudivs in 43AD. They'd largely buggered off by around 400AD.

You have to note that back then, you didn't have to worry about things like planning permission and that possession or "title" to land was generally 9/10ths of the "law" and possession (sorry, title) might involve a bit of violence which was perfectly legal (OK not exactly illegal, given that the Shire Reeve was pissed in a pub 50 miles away and had no idea what was going on).

By the Middle Ages, horses for war use were sodding massive and yet had no air-vents to mount your phone, nor a usable windscreen to mount a dash cam on. That's why we have no evidence of lots of history and stuff.


Replies

pasta67 • today at 4:19 AM

There were many invasions into Britain. Romans, Vikings, Anglo-Saxons, Normans. And before that Corded Ware as well, that fully replaced dna of local population. And some Brits also went away and settled in Bretagne. So, yeah the picture is not as simple as that. The interpretation that you have has more to do with English identity, which is strugling to accept that they once were invaders that certainly were not assimilating into Cornish, Welsh and Cumbrians, while even today dialect differences are present where these various people existed. That and in modern times descendants of common folks assuming identity that was belonging to aristocrate class devoid of any guilt for past and has nothing to do with them.

card_zero • today at 2:11 AM

Planning permission? Here's an incident from around 1170-1200:

> Herbert the dean erected the windmill upon Haberdon. When the abbot heard of this, his anger was so kindled that he would scarcely eat or utter a single word. On the morrow, after hearing Mass, he commanded the sacrist that without delay he should send his carpenters thither and overturn it altogether, and carefully put by the wooden materials in safe keeping. The dean hearing this came to him saying that he was able in law to do this upon his own frank fee, and that the benefit of the wind ought not to be denied to anyone. He further said that he only wanted to grind his own corn there, and noone else’s, lest it should be imagined that he did this to the damage of the neighbouring mills. The abbot, his anger not yet appeased, answered, “ I give you as many thanks as if you had cut off both my feet. By the mouth of God I will not eat bread until that building be plucked down. ...

https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.211497/page/n1...