logoalt Hacker News

faangguyindia • today at 9:11 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

>The Chinese makers are heavily subsidised both by stealing process from Tesla

Elon Musk himself claims, "you are free to clone our satellite and car manufacturing; we only file defensive patents"


Replies

gpt5 • today at 10:19 AM

To be fair, Musk did not sue BYD, despite some widely considered clones of his cars and processes. Other manufacturers did. For example, in the EU, you can't sell the BYD Ti7 because a court ruled it violated Jaguar Land Rover IP.

CMay • today at 11:23 AM

He also said the same thing about their space rockets. I mean generally, China can steal what it wants, but anyone that wants to work on those kinds of things needs approval from their government and replicating anything that SpaceX is doing requires a level of discipline and process that a lot of companies won't be able to match. That said, I'm not sure that all of the why's of internal SpaceX decisions are public, and simply copying something without understanding the why's is probably a good way to end up with things that don't work once you're 1000 decisions deep into what you're doing.

Really what I took from his statements was an emphasis that good execution is harder than you think at the same time as his personal philosophy is shifting to like, machines will make everything so people's personal stakes in their own investment will be discardable. I don't know, he is both very wrong sometimes and a force of nature, so it's anyone's guess.

stuaxo • today at 10:20 AM

He says all sorts of things.