logoalt Hacker News

nkurz • today at 1:27 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

OK, that's a start. Is this because the studies are wrong and increased use of AI isn't actually going to dramatically increase fossil fuel usage, or because increased fossil fuel consumption isn't actually something that we should worry about?

I'm sure there are arguments for both of these (clean energy will quickly replace the dirty initial sources/why worry about decadal scale global warming in the face of FOOM?) but it would help if you actually made some arguments rather than just gesturing.


Replies

adjejmxbdjdn • today at 4:47 PM

It’s hard to see how increased fossil fuel consumption will not be a problem given that we haven’t modeled tipping points at all.

However, focusing on the AI industry is beyond silly.

For example, this article focuses on the 25.7 million metric ton Co2E the 400 largest data centers emit (and I suspect this is data centers, not AI data centers specifically), and let’s say the total data center emission in the U.S. is 3 times that.

So that’s about 75million MTCO2E

Well, the US dairy industry alone emits about 160 million MTCO2E in a year. And dairy is a trivially substitutable product (with half a dozen plant based direct alternatives, but frankly, the US dairy industry would likely collapse if it wasn’t for the subsidies showered on it by the government), nd has a whole host of other issues.

AI on the other hand is doing completely new rhinfs, and is likely more efficient than the alternative ways of doing the same stuff.

If you’re seriously concerned about emissions start with eliminating subsidies to the dairy industry. That alone would wipe out half the industry and buy you enough emissions saved to more than offset AI emissions for another decade.

What this really shows is that this is not being taken seriously but is close to essentially clickbait (the research is necessary, but the idea that AI is even close to the biggest emissions concern is the clickbait aspect).

➕ show 1 reply