Sad because collectively none of us benefit from this. High gas prices, polluted air, geopolitical risk, wars, and increased risk of floods and devastating fires. Plus, it doesn't even scale. We cannot scale AI without cheap energy and fossil fuels will never be as cheap as we need them to be.
Gift link: https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/climate/cop31-climate-sum...
Anywho, I think market forces will take care of this even if governments want to drag their feet. As the price of clean energy drops (and rival countries like China gain might by continuing to fully invest), everyone else will have no choice but to follow.
At this point fossil fuels are economically uncompetitive with solar energy except in fairly polar climates. I just did the math with respect to simple-cycle gas turbines in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50599997 an hour ago.
Even if we all suspended disbelief and somehow came to a unanimous agreement on climate science, solar prices, and how we should wean ourselves off oil, the negotiators would still have a fight on their hands.
You still have some remaining oil business. Who does it go to? Whoever can pump it the cheapest? Whoever has the fewest alternatives for export income? Who’s the most dependable to produce during a war? Each one of these puts a different country out of a ton of jobs.
These rounds of speeches mean nothing. Ask the participants for two numbers: 1. How much oil do you expect the world to buy? 2. How much oil do you expect to sell? I’d learn more from adding up the second column than 20 rounds of hot air.
There are no political solutions. There never were, because nations that "cheat" and take advantage of cheap fossil fuels gain Geopolitical power in turn (See: Russia). Paris 2016 was a joke and the succeeding decade has proven that.
There are only technical solutions. Let's ignite a fusion reactor. Find a way to get grid-scale storage working (stacking up current-gen batteries won't). Drive enough innovation in Fission that it can be safe and cheap. Maybe harness the tides idk
Human nature being what it is, we will not simply walk backwards away from the Energy Sources we can harness. The only way is forwards, into a cleaner and more sustainable way to get more of it.
I think future generations will look back and think it insane that we coupled our entire economy to a substance run by a cartel that is so price-volatile that the price has to be listed on electronic billboards outside gas stations. That one country can start a war across the other side of the world and prices go up for everyone worldwide. And that we chose a fuel that the West has very little of and is controlled by countries mostly hostile to us.
We had warnings in the 70s and still chose to go all-in on oil. We’re now at a point where the technology exists to displace oil but oil is so entrenched in our culture and politics that it’s difficult. I hope that simple ROI will eventually win where political action has failed, but we should have done all of that a few decades ago.
These are the people that represent the rest of us on the world stage.
If they cannot compromise on something that seems to be central to the survival of our species (and possibly all the others), what chance do the rest of us have?
Nobody needs the Middle East to solve the climate crisis: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/primary-energy-source-bar...
There are two aspects to these things:
- Being green from a political posture never brought jobs to the table. Actually investing in energy, recycling and making people do things works, when the politicians jobs are to launder money than invest in real people, who'd listen?
- Many people have actually cheap access to oil and can trade in whatever currencies they want, so they have an option to quickly produce and consume their own oil, leaving all these old energy companies in the dust. Whenever someone blocks it, they are likely to be lobbyists of these old energy companies.
With China's solar boost, this sort of nonsense is going to not shock the world any longer and the people dependent on this gas sector are going to feel the impact of it sooner than later. Wisdom would dictate throwing out these lobbies and investing in local production and consumption of energy. Who's going to do the sane thing though? Not a science issue here, clearly.
There's an interesting correlation with COP talks failing and financial crises.
2000
2009
2019
Now
> Some diplomats said the conference’s credibility would depend on
Does that conference still have any kind of credibility at this point?
Our planet is burning while oligarchs argue over the fossil fuels that are threatening all life on our planet. Because their profits might suffer.
At this point, we know it is really over and we are probably on the way to maybe +5C. I thought I read somewhere in reality scientists are hoping we can keep it below +3.5C, but they are very worried, who listens to them anyway :(
In the US, both political parties have been trying for years to keep gas and diesel fuel prices low. They know they will loose their cushy jobs if fossil fuel prices reach a certain level. A good example of this is the US midterms, the GOP got hammered due to fossil fuel prices.
Yes you can argue it was Trump and other reasons, but I have been around for while and gas prices in the US is the # 1 reason for political change and has been since the 70s.
What should happen ? Fossil Fuel prices need to raise a lot to force a very quick move to alternate sources. Otherwise, off to +5C we go. Yes people will suffer, but suffering, even at +3.5C will be far worse than high fuel prices. Instead we keep prices low by oil subsidies and other incentives.
Does anyone actually believe that these talks will achieve anything concrete? As another commenter has mentioned, only the cost of fossil fuels has any teeth in influencing our behavior. The other factor that will help is the declining birthrate world wide which reduces consumption.
Of course, it’s not all rainbows and butterflies. Higher energy costs results in higher costs in nearly everything including food, heating & cooling costs. Collapsing birthrates mean collapsing economic systems since both socialism and capitalism rely on constantly growing populations.
[dead]
Actually recent events has made cheap oil and gas a thing of the past.
This is the only thing that will stop people from emitting as much CO2 as they want.
If gas in the US was 10$ a gallon you’d see a lot of folks figuring out alternatives. Public transportation, cycling, and of course EVs.
However, this could also lead to famines in lower income countries. The cost of food production surging isn’t a good thing.