logoalt Hacker News

Ask HN: Are the trades a safe career transition?

26 points • by Rd6n6 • today at 3:52 PM • 38 comments • view on HN

I am a software guy. Engineering degree but not PEng. Im thinking of jumping ship because i dont see much of a future in the career. Ai has me a little discouraged

I need a few decades of at least mild security to get to retirement...

Are the trades safe?

Im worried about homeowners and companies ending up with robots that do all those tasks. Not next year obviously, but it could happen before the career change fully pays off

And if not the trades, then what is a better bet?


Comments

Grombobulous • today at 5:37 PM

If you look at a graph of the US economy, and remove software and data centers, there’s basically no growth.

Don’t leave software. AI will change your job, but it won’t replace you, not even in multiple decades.

Be strategic about the kinds of software roles you get into. Look for niches with stability. Look to go toward highly regulated software niches. For example, I work in an area where it would be impossible to remove manual testers due to certain regulations.

Software work for government where you must be a US citizen or you must do specific things manually could be another example.

I also think some areas are going to be more insulated from AI disruption. I think ops and security have more stability. Anything that requires more judgment and less “take inputs and turn them into outputs.”

Moving from an upper middle class career track to something you can get into without a high school diploma is a mistake. In many trades you’re competing with dudes who are working under the table and aren’t even documented. Even if you’re not, they’re mostly hard on your body, and some aren’t even immune from automation.

➕ show 1 reply
jlos • today at 5:49 PM

My family are all trades people, I went into software. I’m also in a region where trades pay well.

Trades are high floor, low ceiling. Initial wages are good, but after journeyman there isn’t much growth. Unless you start your own business, then sky’s the limit.

Trades are hard on the body, there’s very little work-life balance, and they are very boom/must cycle dependent.

Skilled tradesmen who can mix business acumen are rare, thats where I’d aim for.

But for wanting just a “job” software is better and more comfortable. Can always do woodworking in your spare time too.

akmarinov • today at 5:48 PM

Go for pilot, about 40 000€ to get to CPL. Over here in Europe, you’ll match a software dev’s salary in about 4 years.

I imagine in passenger planes, two pilots would be mandated for quite a while, even if they don’t do much. Planes can fly on autopilot and can now land/take off automatically, but I don’t see people getting on a plane with no pilot.

Once the Russian and US wars wrap up - there’ll be more demand for flights.

Freight flights are over though, drones will take over there.

seanmcdirmid • today at 5:18 PM

Trades are boom bust even more so than software engineering. There is a shortage, people run to the field, but by the time they are trained up (end of apprenticeship) there is probably a bust because there are too many people in them. You need to be prepared to sweat out at least one bust at the beginning of your career, and stay in it so you can reap a boom or two.

It’s definitely an exciting time to be in robotics, though it looks like the Chinese are pushing more aggressively into it thsn western developed nations. AI is also a huge risk to the trades (the joke about the plumber just needing to know hit im a call means those quick calls are at risk because that knowledge is easy to get with a chat bot).

trio8453 • today at 5:47 PM

Safe professions aren't safe.

If all knowledge work disappears, you'll live in an economy that's so unstable from high unemployment that it will hardly matter whether your specific chosen profession isn't automated - on the mild end it will affect the demand for what you do, the cost of everything you need to live, your retirement savings, how you get taxed and what your taxes are spent on; on the more extreme end, it won't matter that being a plumber gets you nice house if there people outside throwing bricks through the windows.

allenrb • today at 5:36 PM

I’ve never worked as a professional tradesman, but I’ve done quite a bit of that type of work. It’s hard. It’s hard on your body in ways that will become more of an issue as you age. It’s also, imho, very satisfying work. But it’s tough. And even though you might look at your last plumbing bill and say “damn, that would be good money!” the reality is that very few in the trades will bring all of that home themselves.

As for AI in the software field… I’ve watched the people around me. Some of them are doing good work with AI. And what they all have in common is serious skill and experience predating AI. What it looks like from my seat is that AI in software dev and related fields is absolutely a force multiplier… but only for people who already know what they’re doing.

So as a few other people have said, don’t be too hasty to jump ship. There may yet be some good opportunities.

Btw, having said all of that, my AI use is limited to summarizing searches and assisting on code review. I’m personally quite “anti AI” and close enough to retirement that if eventually I can’t keep up without going all-in, I’m ok with being fired. Love my job and the people I work with, though.

bruce511 • today at 5:45 PM

I work primarily in a language that was most popular in the early 90s. As its popularity declined lots of people "jumped ship" (preemptively) to other languages.

For some it went well, for others the think they jumped too has died already. Some discovered that having main-stream skills just makes you a small fish in an enormous pond.

Which is to say that predicting the future is hard. And predicting what skills will be most valuable 30 years from now is pretty impossible.

Yes, I know the present is scary, especially if you are just starting out. All you can do is be adaptable. It's unlikely the tasks you are accomplishing today will be what you are doing 5 years from now.

pfannkuchen • today at 5:16 PM

AI is definitely changing things a lot in the field, but don't discount the massive change in how cheap money was during ZIRP and how expensive it became after ZIRP finally ended. This was coincidentally around the same time the layoffs in big tech started, which was before AI really had any meaningful impact. When money is cheap it is a lot easier for companies to hire, and when money suddenly stops being cheap it is a lot harder.

In particular, large discontinuities in economic conditions, which we just experienced recently post-covid, always produce downturns in affected industries (which is distinct from the first order aspect of how expensive money is). So I think even ignoring AI we could expect several years of down-ness and reorganization followed by a recovery.

I don't think we can even tell this point if AI will reduce demand for developers. The economy for software might be even worse right now if the AI developments hadn't happened when they did, there was an insane hiring spree during COVID and even before that the industry employment-side was growing at a probably unsustainable pace.

➕ show 1 reply
captainkrtek • today at 5:45 PM

I’ve been in software 14 years. My older brother career transitioned to an electrician, its hard work but pays well and he is in a union. Compared to software eng though its much harder and is a multi year grind during apprenticeship. It is also boom/bust, as he has to sit without work for multiple times a year as projects start up and finish seasonally.

neom • today at 5:05 PM

They're making pretty good progress on hands[1,2], I don't have a good sense of how quickly these things will become cheap enough to become ubiquitous, I'd imagine > 5 years but < 10 years. One Policy and Zero Prior Learning are making very good progress[3,4,5].

Plummer is probably the safest of the trades if I had to guess. That said, I'd encourage you to think more about other things humans are likely to always want/need - see if any of the other options are interesting to you? For example, lots of people are and will continue to be lonely, having a bar to sit at with someone friendly/interesting is a tool we use for this (I wrote a blog post about this idea: https://b.h4x.zip/finale/) - but there are also things like undertakers, kids activities centers/camp councilor, etc. Not all of these things will be equally financially rewarding, but maybe you're able to think about rewarding in other ways. :)

[1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4whgw2gLBS8

[2]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C5MsqzQW8X4

[3]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhK28R9J-DQ

[4]https://nico-bohlinger.github.io/one_policy_to_run_them_all_...

[5]https://www.pi.website/blog/api-beta

➕ show 1 reply
x-tangle • today at 5:18 PM

In our world of hammers, the nail gun was invented and we can now simply build faster. If your plan was to keep typing code yourself, its definitly coming to an end, but your skills can be transformed to take advantage of those new tools and accomplish so much more than you could before.

➕ show 1 reply
Tade0 • today at 5:31 PM

> Are the trades safe?

The running joke is that they're called "the trades" because you trade your health for money. Not trying to discourage you, but be mindful of this. Also they're often accessible only with proper licences, which take time to acquire.

My personal plan B is learning an uncommon foreign language. I'm not a native English speaker and yet I'm here, writing this comment, so to me it's just a question of putting some time into learning.

AI is great at context-aware translation in writing. But if you want to actually communicate, better really learn the language.

hingler36 • today at 5:23 PM

Others have made great points, but one aspect people tend to underestimate is how rough the trades are on your body. A lifetime career of crouching, resting on your knees, and contorting your body into tight spaces leaves you in rough shape in your old age.

lordnacho • today at 5:43 PM

Markets are generally quite good at making every choice look marginal.

If you get paid a lot, it's hard to pass interviews.

If it looks easy, there's some hidden drawback.

If it seems like it will always be needed, someone is working on a replacement.

If it looks well protected, it's from new entrants.

bombcar • today at 5:42 PM

Your advantage in the trades would be to be the software guy.

Most trades are small businesses, relatively badly managed, and pretty incompetent outside of their core competencies. You could add value there.

bix6 • today at 5:23 PM

Can you stand on your feet in the blazing sun for 8 hours? Are you willing to work Saturdays? Most people who work white collar cannot and the pay is often not as good, especially as you work your way up.

➕ show 1 reply
exhilaration • today at 5:17 PM

Check the trades subreddits (hvac, plumbing, electric) - lots of people not being able to find jobs or get into apprenticeships. Words like "oversaturated". My feeling is that we're 5-10 years too late but it might vary by region.

CoolestBeans • today at 5:19 PM

Trades are very cyclical and offer little in the way of a safety net. You'll have fat and lean years. The lean years will wipe you out unless you're a phenomenal saver and can keep your lifestyle monk like during the fat years.

You will probably be safe from the sort of automation around the corner as the boom is largely contained in the virtual world. There is no such thing as job security in a dynamic economy like ours. The ones who are the most successful are the ones who can stick and move and are unsentimental about what work they are doing.

serf • today at 4:04 PM

I guess safe is a relative term.

I've met a lot more 9 fingered mechanics than software developers.

>jumping ship

that sure seems unwise to throw away a position in a time of pre-supposed insecurity.

patadura • today at 5:19 PM

Not sure if this applies to many others, at least for me I started using llm a lot for thing that you would normally call a handyman. Obviously this doesn't apply to places where you need a license but I expect automation there to increase a lot.

QuadmasterXLII • today at 5:00 PM

The only careers where you can have certainty about what will happen to your job after the robots are better than you are chess grandmaster and marathon runner.

➕ show 2 replies
jqpabc123 • today at 5:44 PM

Start with the realization that unless you are just plain lucky (as a result of birth for example), security is something that is usually self made.

Regardless of the industry, wage slavery is insecure by design . The threat of losing your job is ever present and used as a motivating factor. Even when it is not being overtly stated, it remains an option that is never far away from being utilized.

Real security is control over your own destiny. And the only way I know to achieve a reasonable measure of it by running your own business. It doesn't really matter what kind of business but is best to pick something you have some interest in.

Just as an example, I know a guy with lots of financial security. He owns a string of barber shops and hair salons. He started out by learning to cut hair but nowadays, the only thing he cuts is checks to his employees --- while taking a sizeable "cut" for himself. If AI robots learn how to cut hair, he has the money to buy some, adapt and continue on with his business.

readthenotes1 • today at 5:43 PM

I generally talk to the tradesman who work around my house and the happiest ones were the gas line people.

No one ever rushes them and everyone's happy to see them. Plenty of overtime.

I got the feeling that it's pretty hard work and long hours and of course the danger of explosion. But somehow the crew was happy.

johnea • today at 5:43 PM

Don't listen to the people who are afraid to leave their computer!

Trades continue to boom.

Personally, I'd pick electrician.

Plumbers also do very well, but in addition to dealing with the water flowing in, you have to deal with the shit flowing out 8-/

A lot of modern electrical installations are on a level of an advanced engineering technician.

The work isn't as physically taxing as other trades, but it is still physical. Pulling conduit is hard work.

But the pay is good, and it'll leave you fit. You'll probably live longer...

65 • today at 5:42 PM

Everyone is wildly obsessed with "the trades" these days, it's become a media buzzword.

I don't know why everyone thinks knowledge work is going to implode and only "the trades" are going to exist. How can all those people that lost their jobs to AI afford to hire a plumber to fix their toilet? How can the property developers afford to hire carpenters when all those knowledge workers lost their jobs and can't afford housing?

Society just doesn't work this way, and likewise no one wants there to be some kind of imminent collapse. It's far more likely you'll get hired to do something soul crushingly boring or useless in the future compared to the wild and crazy idea of doom and gloom AI terminator fantasy. I can imagine many jobs becoming bullshit jobs. If you give someone a job, they can afford to buy things, and them buying things keeps the economy working.

thraway3837 • today at 5:41 PM

Depends on the area. High GDP metro? Sure! But you’d have to work for a family owned business first before you start to build your client list. Middle America , rust belt? A lot of those plumbing electrical shops are owned by PE firms and people don’t have as much money to fix stuff or renovate as the high GDP areas.

It’s not easy work. Lots of potential for injury and seasonal boom and busts. So it depends on your current finances. Also have to be an apprentice first and finish the licensing exams.

realusername • today at 5:11 PM

I'd wait a bit before jumping ships, the future is always different from what people think it will be. If you are really worried, you can get some training in a different job right now and keep it as a plan B.

dude250711 • today at 5:20 PM

Depending on your specific choice, it might not be safe for e.g. your knees and back.

viklove • today at 5:17 PM

I'm starting a new business called handjobs for billionaires. Gotta get with the K-shaped economy. We all just create luxury products for the ruling class now. Bend the knee or be left behind.