logoalt Hacker News

andai • today at 4:13 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

>Pesticides? According to the WHO-UNEP report, prenatal exposure (as of 2010) to a single family of these products (organophosphates) was, for example, responsible for more than 59,300 cases of intellectual disability per year in European Union (EU) countries. Due to maternal exposure to just this one category of pesticides, a European child born in 2010 lost, on average, about 2.5 IQ points, according to the panel of researchers brought together by WHO and UNEP.

>Still based on population exposure levels in 2010, DDT – a highly persistent insecticide – although banned since the 1970s, was responsible for 56,700 annual cases of uterine fibroids in the EU, 28,200 cases of type 2 diabetes and 1,550 cases of childhood obesity. Even these figures provide only a small glimpse of the situation, as high-quality data are not available for the overwhelming majority of the approximately 400 pesticides registered in Europe.

>When it comes to plasticizers and industrial pollutants, the picture is no different. Exposure (in 2010) to DEHP in Europe caused 145,000 annual cases of endometriosis, 20,500 cases of diabetes and 53,900 cases of obesity. Phthalates in general? They accounted for 618,000 annual cases of male infertility in Europe. Bisphenol A caused 42,400 cases of childhood obesity per year in Europe. And if anyone thinks the press exaggerates the issue of forever chemicals (PFAS, or "per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances"), the WHO-UNEP report reminds us that in the US, where 2018 data allow such an estimate, more than four million cases of obesity are attributable to the two most-studied PFAS, as well as 127,000 annual cases of childhood obesity and 14,000 cases of hypothyroidism.


Replies

WillPostForFood • today at 5:41 PM

This is based on a study that didn't directly measures the health effects or economic costs of chemical exposure. It wass a modeling exercise that combines observational studies, animal experiments, exposure estimates, economic assumptions, and opinion. Basically very low quality.

➕ show 1 reply
GrantMoyer • today at 5:31 PM

For a sense of scale, compare to the WHO fact sheet for alcohol use in Europe[1]:

> One in every 11 deaths in the WHO European Region is due to alcohol consumption. About 800,000 deaths a year result from alcohol use in the Region, almost a third of the global total of 2.6 million deaths [from alcohol use].

> In the WHO European Region, more than 1 in every 11 adults experiences alcohol use disorders.

> Alcohol consumption is responsible for 1 in 4 deaths of 19–24-year-olds in the WHO European Region, mainly due to injuries.

I don't bring this up to excuse manufactures of harmful chemicals from producing those harmful chemicals, especially when in some cases there's evidence the manufacturers knew the chemicals were harmful and covered it up. Neither do I want to excuse those manufactures from negligently or intentionally dumping potentially or known harmful chemicals into the environment. I don't excuse regulators from allowing these behaviors either, but I do see where the perspective of "the diseases are mostly caused by peoples own choices" comes from, and how problems like harmful pollution might seem lower priority compared to other issues.

Ultimately though, those view don't hold up. Tackling these sources of public health issues can happen in parallel, and some of these relatively smaller scale issues with well defined causes are certainly easier to address than changing peoples behavior at scale.

[1]: https://www.who.int/europe/news-room/fact-sheets/item/alcoho...

➕ show 3 replies