logoalt Hacker News

jcranmer • today at 4:34 PM • 0 replies • view on HN

> Even the senate voting to enter a treaty might not be of much help, as there's precedent for the president to withdraw from treaties without congressional approval.

There's some complication here that's often elided. Per the US Constitution, all treaties have to be ratified by the Senate, and it's generally held that such treaties have to be abrogated by act of Congress (SCOTUS has never actually heard a case, since treaty abrogation is generally something they dodge as nonjusticiable in the first place).

However, a lot of "treaties" these days signed by the US are actually "executive agreements," which bypass the need for ⅔ majority vote in the Senate. Since they're made under the (potentially delegated) authority of the executive alone, they're able to be abrogated by that same authority of the executive alone.