logoalt Hacker News

lotsofpulp • today at 4:38 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

The entire reason Democrats swept the elections is because Republicans caused high fossil fuel prices. Any effective bill to reduce fossil fuel consumption in a a relevant timeframe will need to cause fossil fuel prices to go much higher, which will again cause Americans to vote for the other party.

People do not want to slow climate change, they want their houses in the suburbs, their big cars, their electronics, their out-of-season foods, and their cheap flights.


Replies

cogman10 • today at 5:30 PM

> Any effective bill to reduce fossil fuel consumption in a a relevant timeframe will need to cause fossil fuel prices to go much higher

Arguably if the bill is effective then it will end up doing the opposite and end up causing fossil fuel prices to tumble (because fewer entities are consuming them).

It's also possible to use the revenue from taxes/fines to help fund social programs which decrease the costs. Even something as simple as a fossil fuel rebate check would go a long way towards buying good will.

For examples of what could be done which would reduce fossil fuel consumption without negatively impacting (most) people. Public transport funds for states. Building out amtrak and high speed rail (dedicated lines rather than shared lines). Heavy heavy taxes on private jets... or better yet simply outlaw them all together, everyone that flies should do it commercially.

> they want their houses in the suburbs

The majority of people want affordable housing. That means cheap apartments ideally within walking distance of their work.

> their big cars

There's not much of an option in the american market, cheaper sedans have a place but fewer manufacturers are offering them. Making big cars more expensive and sedans/minivans/station wagons cheaper would shift market preferences. As of now, those vehicles are practically specialty vehicles and aren't significantly discounted over a monster truck or SUV.

> their electronics

Consumer electronics are not a major driver of climate change. Heating and cooling and transport still dominate in terms of what the average american is emitting.

> their out-of-season foods

This one might seem pretty surprising, but that's not actually a climate change driver. In terms of emissions, shipping by water (which is how most people get those out-of-season foods) emits relatively little CO2 for the amount of goods moved. The bigger issue is the semi-trucks moving the banana instead of the boat moving the banana. Boats are more efficient than trains and trains are freakishly efficient.

> and their cheap flights.

As I mentioned above, eliminating private jet flights would go a LONG way in cutting down flight emissions. Commercial flights are about twice as bad as a car driving the same distance. The way you make less people fly is by making trains better and cheaper. As of right now, trains are MUCH slower than even driving and as expensive or more expensive than flying. In the US they are also plagued with delay because they share lines with private shipping companies.

➕ show 1 reply