logoalt Hacker News

notamy10/01/20248 repliesview on HN

https://gbatemp.net/threads/ryujinx-emulator-github-reposito...

> UPDATE #3: According to an official statement on Ryujinx's Discord server, developer gdkchan was contacted by Nintendo and they were offered an agreement to stop working on the emulator project, and while the agreement wasn't confirmed yet, the organization has been entirely removed.


Replies

Liquix10/01/2024

> it's not a DMCA, it's not an issue with GitHub.

glaring omission of the statement "it's not an issue with Nintendo". they have a reputation for relentlessly pursuing the creators of homebrew/emu projects like this. sometimes even going as far as contracting operatives to stalk hobby devs living outside of Japan. look up "nintendo ninjas"...

show 1 reply
jsheard10/01/2024

RE: Update 3 (gdkchan being "encouraged" to step down)

I'm mostly just surprised it took Nintendo this long to make a move - the Switch is on its last legs, its successor is less than a year away and almost certainly won't be hacked for a good while. Acting in a way that's bound to piss everyone off but doing it so late that the upside to them is minimal (there won't be that many more new Switch games to pirate at this point) is a weird unforced error. Lawyers move in mysterious ways I guess.

show 4 replies
duxup10/01/2024

I get the message but this is one of those things where you should have YOUR explanation ready before you pause everything...

Granted that's understandable if they didn't choose the timeline.

show 1 reply
ndiddy10/01/2024

In case anyone's curious about Nintendo's general MO (not sure how similar this case is) around 10 years ago they successfully prevented someone from publishing a method to run arbitrary code on the 3DS using an NDA and the threat of legal action. Here's some documents detailing their approach: https://archive.org/details/Knock_And_Talk_directcontact/Kno...

alfalfasprout10/01/2024

Given that Ryujinx is open source, I wonder what rights other OSS contributors have? Surely there's nothing stopping another fork from continued development provided nothing illegal is happening.

show 1 reply
nurettin10/01/2024

Interesting, I wonder if this means that they got paid.

koolala10/01/2024

A threat is not a natural 'agreement'.

ls61210/01/2024

I mean it's hard to imagine this being anything other than the worst.