logoalt Hacker News

huijzer11/20/20242 repliesview on HN

Prof. Stephen Kotkin — an historian who wrote multiple extensive biographies on Stalin — calls the Russian regime a "gangster regime".*

Once you see them as gangsters, it's not difficult to see why they would do this.

*A full link with exact timestamp of Kotkin saying this is [1]. Here he talks about why Merkel kept making oil deals with Putin even though in hindsight this was probably not the best idea. Kotkin argues that, yes, according to econ 101 trade is good for both parties, but not when the opposite party is a gangster. Merkel thought that Putin was thinking like her, but he wasn't.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/live/jJSDdCPpbto?t=4410


Replies

mopsi11/20/2024

It should be noted that Putin was personally an enforcer for St Petersburg's mayor Anatoly Sobchak[1] in the early 1990s, and his "circle of friends" from that time now mans key positions of the entire government. For example, Viktor Zolotov[2], Sobchak's bodyguard and Putin's judo partner, is now in charge of National Guard, despite not having qualifications for the job.

Russia is literally run buy thugs who ran protection rackets not so long ago. So there's much more to this than just a fitting figure of speech. Someone from the worst parts of LA would be better equipped to understand and deal with such people than those who spent their teens and early adulthood playing Model UN at a foreign relations club.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatoly_Sobchak

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Zolotov

euroderf11/20/2024

One theme of cyberpunk is that Russia remains a gangster regime in the future. William Gibson's "Kombinat".