logoalt Hacker News

petekoomen04/23/20254 repliesview on HN

Agreed! As i mentioned in the piece I don't think LLMs are very useful for original writing because instructing an agent to write anything from scratch inevitably takes more time than writing it yourself.

Most of the time I spend managing my inbox is not spent on original writing, however. It's spent on mundane tasks like filtering, prioritizing, scheduling back-and-forths, introductions etc. I think an agent could help me with a lot of that, and I dream of a world in which I can spend less time on email and finally be one of those "inbox zero" people.


Replies

Retric04/23/2025

The counter argument is some people are terrible at writing. Millions of people sit at the bottom of any given bell curve.

I’d never trust a summery from a current generation LLM for something as critical as my inbox. Some hypothetical drastically improved future AI, sure.

show 1 reply
derektank04/24/2025

For the case of writing emails, I tend to agree though I think creative writing is an exception. Pairing with an LLM really helps overcome the blank page / writer's block problem because it's often easier to identify what you don't want and then revise all the flaws you see.

elieskilled04/24/2025

On that topic I’m the founder of inbox zero: https://getinboxzero.com

May help you get half way there

rahimnathwani04/24/2025

  instructing an agent to write anything from scratch inevitably takes more time than writing it yourself
But you can reuse your instructions with zero additional effort. I have some instructions that I wrote for a 'Project' in Claude (and now a 'Gem' in Gemini). The instructions give writing guidelines for a children's article about a topic. So I just write 'write an article about cross-pollination' and a minute later I have an article I can hand to my son.

Even if I had the subject matter knowledge, it would take me much longer to write an article with the type of style and examples that I want.

(Because you said 'from scratch', I deliberately didn't choose an example that used web search or tools.)