logoalt Hacker News

jeroenhdyesterday at 11:02 AM1 replyview on HN

What apps in Google's ecosystem have the "all files" permission? Google Drive certainly doesn't. The "upload" button on GDrive prompts you to select a file just like NextCloud does.

The "sync just one folder" functionality exists in SAF without any high-risk permissions. Migration of existing profiles may be a pain (as the user would need to grant permission on the folder when switching to the new API).

Synchronisation of the entire virtual storage, the download folder, or any extra folders vendors like Samsung might've added to the blacklist, isn't possible with the new API, but it's also not possible with Google's own services. The DMA only requires Google not to be put in a special position; as long as they don't offer such a feature, they don't need to offer it to NextCloud.


Replies

apitmanyesterday at 11:25 PM

> What apps in Google's ecosystem have the "all files" permission?

The system itself[0] has capabililities that aren't provided to app developers. iOS is similar. Contrast this with Windows and GNU/Linux where AFAIK you can do pretty much everything the OS can given the proper permissions. Not sure about macOS.

[0]: https://support.google.com/googleone/answer/9149304?hl=en&co...