logoalt Hacker News

blindedyesterday at 3:46 PM6 repliesview on HN

Guess the sarcastic response would be: "so a bus?"


Replies

babyshakeyesterday at 4:17 PM

If it is busses that show their live position and ETA until your pickup location, that would be a significant improvement on the status quo. Bus schedules tend to be pretty unreliable in areas with traffic.

show 8 replies
nickffyesterday at 4:22 PM

There are many places where private busses are the norm; in many countries these private operates have been crowded-out by subsidized governmental competitors, but there may be room for some now.

show 2 replies
dmixyesterday at 4:26 PM

It says maximum of 3 people in a ride (at least the current plan) so not really.

jrflowersyesterday at 5:00 PM

It is also not sarcastic to point out that a bus is a bus.

riehwvfbkyesterday at 4:22 PM

Well, no. In a low density US city a bus route goes into all the places where nobody is waiting in the name of increasing coverage. Adding more routes is impossible due to lack of funding. This makes it take 2-3 times as long as a car to get anywhere, which it then makes buses transportation of last resort. Which further decreases ridership and funding.

A municipal service cannot implement on-demand hailing because it has to serve the one or two people who can't use a phone (never mind that it would be cheaper to hire a personal assistant for them to book their rides). And so innovation is left to private enterprises.

Here come the downvotes! However, on a sibling thread about on-demand buses in China the same folks will praise innovation...

show 5 replies