logoalt Hacker News

tacker2000yesterday at 1:27 PM1 replyview on HN

Not every city needs a ring line, or has a geographical shape where it would be practical.

Manhattan is a long rectangle, whilst Berlin has a more rounded shape.

Its faster to cross the small width of the rectangle than to go all the way around.


Replies

PaulHouleyesterday at 2:18 PM

It's perceived as a problem around NYC that a lot of people might want to go from Brooklyn to Queens or to Harlem and the Bronx but public transit funnels everyone through downtown or midtown Manhattan. NYC doesn't need a ring but it could use a supplementary arc.

show 2 replies