logoalt Hacker News

logicchains06/16/20252 repliesview on HN

Entropy isn't a function of imperfect knowledge. It's a function of the possible states of a system and their probability distributions. Quantum mechanics assumes, as the name implies, that reality at the smallest level can be quantised, so it's completely appropriate to apply entropy to describing things at the microscopic scale.


Replies

aurareturn06/16/2025

If we knew the exact state of all particles in an enclosed system, we can calculate what future states will be exactly. No need to calculate possible states.

show 2 replies
kgwgk06/16/2025

> Entropy isn't a function of imperfect knowledge. It's a function of the possible states of a system and their probability distributions.

There are no probability distributions over possible states when there is perfect knowledge of the state.

> Quantum mechanics

Entropy is also zero for a pure quantum state. You won’t have entropy without imperfect knowledge.

show 2 replies