logoalt Hacker News

mothballedyesterday at 2:30 PM6 repliesview on HN

I don't own a phone, but the most shocking revelation came when my child's school required us to use an app to specify how our children will be picked up or ride the bus.

So far I've been able to avoid using apps for pretty much anything, but when the school says "use an app or you won't get your kids" and then also say they will call CPS and have your kids seized if you don't get them in time, that puts you in a real fucked up situation.


Replies

rhinesyesterday at 3:06 PM

We've reached the point where people without devices or common online services are so rare that society no longer accommodates them. It's similar to how we need legislation to ensure that disabled people have accessible infrastructure, except I doubt there will ever be legislation mandating offline/off-app accessibility.

show 5 replies
W3zzyyesterday at 3:06 PM

I work for some local governments in Belgium and with every system they put in place I keep insisting on a analogous version. Online forms? Great but if anyone chooses the should be able to send in a paper form or get assisted by someone who fills in the online form for them.

show 1 reply
stock_toastertoday at 3:58 AM

I'm sure the app is perfectly ADA complaint too. /sarcasm

etherealGyesterday at 4:49 PM

I think I might enjoy the CPS scenario... let them call CPS, and wait for CPS to arrive, and then discuss with CPS who is endangering the child, the parent or the school. I'm pretty sure a judge will quickly decide whether their rule makes sense or not, and I think judges in child protection cases are going to quickly side with what's important for the child.

I HATE this kind of nonsense, and threatening you as a parent is only making things worse. Why not offer a way to handle this on a simple website? It would have lower cost to the school and be more accessible to anyone with any device able to access websites. Nonsense.

show 2 replies
1over137today at 12:41 AM

What country is that in?!??

show 1 reply
bigstrat2003yesterday at 6:35 PM

That's pretty fucked. It should be utterly illegal to put parents in a triple bind like that. You have my sympathies.