logoalt Hacker News

tpurvesyesterday at 4:18 PM5 repliesview on HN

What you are describing has been proposed before, for example within context of projects like Breakthrough Starshot. In that the case the idea is to launch thousands of probes, each weighing only a few grams or less, and accelerating them to an appreciable fraction of the speed of light using solar sails and (powerful) earth-based lasers. The probes could reach alpha centauri within 20-30 years. There seems to be some debate though about whether cross-links between probes to enable relaying signals is ever practical from a power and mass perspective vs a single very large receiver on earth.


Replies

Tepixyesterday at 4:23 PM

Indeed. I think the main reason to send thousands of probes is increasing the odds that they will survive the trip and also be in the right position to gather usable data to transmit back.

Also once you have created the infrastructure of hundreds or thousands of very powerful lasers to accelerate the tiny probes to incredibel speeds, sending many probes instead of a few doesn't add much to the cost anyway.

show 1 reply
chmod775today at 10:46 AM

What these proposals like to forget (even if addressing everything else) is that you need to slow down once you arrive if you want to have any time at all for useful observation once you reach your destination.

What's the point of reaching alpha centauri in 30 years if you're gonna zip past everything interesting in seconds? Will the sensors we can cram on tiny probes even be able to capture useful data at all under these conditions?

show 2 replies
dbacaryesterday at 5:58 PM

If I don't recall wrongly, Breakthrough Starshot was not a means for commnunicaiton relay as he describes.

show 1 reply
EGregtoday at 1:08 AM

I bet you that this hasn't been proposed, though: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GfClJxdQ6Xs

I found that video very interesting! Especially the second half about apparent superliminal speed

show 1 reply