logoalt Hacker News

Rust in the kernel is no longer experimental

319 pointsby rascultoday at 3:15 AM144 commentsview on HN

Comments

tzurytoday at 7:29 AM

  > Mike: rachel and i are no longer dating
  >
  > rachel: mike that's a horrible way of telling people we're married
from the meme section on that page.
show 2 replies
hgs3today at 7:37 AM

Rust in the kernel feels like a red herring. For fault tolerance and security, wouldn’t it be a superior solution to migrate Linux to a microkernel architecture? That way, drivers and various other components could be isolated in sandboxes.

show 4 replies
dcrazytoday at 5:20 AM

Does the removal of “experimental” now mean that all maintainers are now obligated to not break Rust code?

show 2 replies
markus_zhangtoday at 3:57 AM

Not a system programmer -- at this point, does C hold any significant advantage over Rust? Is it inevitable that everything written in C is going to be gradually converted to safer languages?

show 20 replies
epohstoday at 3:44 AM

This seems big. Is this big?

show 1 reply
andersmurphytoday at 6:08 AM

I guess it's time to finally try FreeBSD.

show 1 reply
shmerltoday at 5:12 AM

The title sounded worse than it is.

m00dytoday at 4:41 AM

C++ devs are spinning in their graves now.

show 1 reply
arilottertoday at 3:47 AM

This title is moderately clickbait-y and comes with a subtle implication that Rust might be getting removed from the kernel. IMO it should be changed to "Rust in the kernel is no longer experimental"

show 9 replies
wewewedxfgdftoday at 4:46 AM

Oh dear can you imagine the crushing complexity of a future Rust kernel.

show 5 replies
anotherhuetoday at 3:45 AM

Safety is good.

show 3 replies
RustSupremacisttoday at 4:22 AM

[flagged]

nibmantoday at 3:53 AM

[dead]

p0w3n3dtoday at 5:58 AM

They had me in the first half of the article, not gonna lie. I thought they resigned because Rust was so complicated and unsuitable, but it's the opposite

semiinfinitelytoday at 6:20 AM

This is great because it means someday (possibly soon) Linux development will slowly grind to a halt and become unmaintainable, so we can start from scratch and write a new kernel.

Simplitatoday at 6:37 AM

I’m curious how they’ll manage long term safety without the guarantees Rust brought. That tradeoff won’t age well.

show 2 replies