logoalt Hacker News

thinkingemotelast Friday at 6:15 PM6 repliesview on HN

I like the idea and encourage software workers unions. Is there an umbrella union that they can belong to? How effective are these new unions? I imagine these new tech unions don't have the same "shop floor" power as in industry. Why is this?

Perhaps generally the ideals the new unions are advocating for are different than traditional ones?


Replies

paxyslast Friday at 6:59 PM

While things can be bad in software in general, game developers need a union more than anyone. Conditions in that industry are horrendous. The entire period of a game's development is "crunch time". Everyone is exempt, so no overtime of course. And it is standard practice to downsize studios and have mass layoffs right after big launches. It's a shame that so many are drawn to this just because of a passion for gaming.

show 4 replies
dragonwriterlast Friday at 7:19 PM

> Is there an umbrella union that they can belong to?

The article here mentions the umbrella union that this effort was associated with, Communications Workers of America (which itself is part of AFL-CIO.)

IPFTE, I think, also organizes software developers along with other professional and technical workers, and SEIU has a lot in the public and nonprofit sectors.

wrslast Friday at 6:30 PM

If you want that, you’d have to negotiate for it, and now doesn’t seem like a great time.

But given the continual decrease in job stability in tech, perhaps we’re headed toward more of a Hollywood model, where the skilled workers are nearly all free-lance and project-based, and have powerful unions with such provisions industry-wide.

show 1 reply
collinmcnultylast Friday at 7:17 PM

According to the article, they are part of the Communications Workers of America.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Workers_of_Amer...

show 1 reply
doctorpanglosslast Friday at 7:04 PM

Situation: There are 14 competing unions.

You: That's ridiculous! We need one universal union that covers everyone's needs. Yeah!

Situation: There are 15 competing unions.

show 2 replies
nitwit005last Friday at 6:45 PM

With a factory, the owner has to deal with the cost of all the late or canceled deliveries. With farms, the crops wither on the vines.

There's not really an equivalent with most service industries. Software engineers don't even need to be around for the programs to keep running.

show 6 replies