logoalt Hacker News

Manuel_Dlast Friday at 7:12 PM4 repliesview on HN

The workers aren't drones, they have the agency to choose another job. If a company is underpaying workers relative to the rest of the market, they'll struggle to hire and retain employees without the interference of a union.


Replies

palmotealast Friday at 8:36 PM

> The workers aren't drones, they have the agency to choose another job. If a company is underpaying workers relative to the rest of the market, they'll struggle to hire and retain employees without the interference of a union.

The problem is that all employers have certain common interests, and they are generally more organized and powerful than individual workers, which biases the market status-quo in their favor. The market doesn't fix that.

show 1 reply
IshKebablast Friday at 7:33 PM

This is the magical "perfect competition" view of the market that often doesn't match reality at all.

show 2 replies
jimbokunlast Friday at 8:27 PM

There are a lot of defacto cartels where all of the corporations determine a ceiling on wages they won't go over.

There was a big case with Apple and other Silicon Valley corporations were found to have colluded to not hire employees working for any of the other companies.

show 1 reply
salawatlast Friday at 8:26 PM

Oh, yes, because we've never seen a case where large companies entered into no poach agreements to suppress worker wages, right?

Oh wait... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...

Quit the gaslighting.

show 1 reply