logoalt Hacker News

JoeAltmaierlast Monday at 1:05 PM5 repliesview on HN

Folks like to hate on capital gains tax. I think it's perceived as a rich-person deal. But homeowners, do they get taxed each year on the increase in value of their house? Almost the same thing, but not hated on the same way.


Replies

smallmancontrovlast Monday at 1:12 PM

Homeowners get taxed every year on the value of their property. Let's do that to stocks, too.

show 3 replies
giaourlast Monday at 3:07 PM

Yes, I pay property taxes every year that are based on the current assessed values of my home and car. Only special classes of assets are subject to property taxes. "Wealth tax" proposals are a generalization of the idea of real property taxes so as to stop penalizing specific asset classes like homes.

show 1 reply
JKCalhounlast Monday at 4:27 PM

You live in a house. Secondary residences however are not tax deductible?

show 1 reply
bluecheese452last Tuesday at 12:10 AM

Yes? Their property tax goes up.

insane_dreamerlast Monday at 7:08 PM

yes, we do. it's called a property tax, and it goes up based on market value regardless of whether you sold the property or not.

it is absolutely a tax on unrealized gains

and it's a huge problem to where people who bought the house long ago (or it was passed down to them) but whose income hasn't kept pace (like many people's) can't afford the increased property taxes anymore and have to move