logoalt Hacker News

SilverElfintoday at 4:31 PM4 repliesview on HN

This rant has some truth in it but it goes too far and comes off as unbalanced. From the conclusion:

> This was never about addressing privacy, propaganda, or national security. It was always about the U.S. stealing ownership of one of the most popular and successful short form video apps in history because companies like Facebook were too innovatively incompetent to dethrone them in the open market. Ultimately this bipartisan accomplishment not only makes everything worse, it demonstrates we’re absolutely no better than the countries we criticize.

I think when PAFACA passed and set up a ban of TikTok, it was in fact about privacy and propaganda and national security. It’s just that the Trump administration looks at every single situation as an opportunity for grift and corruption, and they abused the opportunity.

The deal does shift algorithmic control and moderation to US based entities. I am not sure what that means in reality. Maybe they can just say they’re in control but choose to use the existing system? Who knows. The terms of the deal look like they help with the original concerns on the face of it.


Replies

wmftoday at 4:52 PM

Are they even stealing anything or are they buying the top?

basiswordtoday at 4:49 PM

>> This was never about addressing privacy, propaganda, or national security.

I disagree. I think was about making sure Americans see the "RIGHT" propaganda.

show 1 reply
benatoday at 4:49 PM

I'm also a little "meh" on the "innovatively incompetent" bit.

People get tunnel-vision. Facebook is for "Facebook things", TikTok is for "TikTok things". Reels, stories, whatevers isn't "TikTok".

It's why Facebook bought Instagram. No matter if Facebook copied Instagram down to the pixel, it still wouldn't be Instagram. And it's why the branding has remained consistent.

Same thing with Google and YouTube.

It's why these acquisitions happen and why these companies become something else. Google to Alphabet, Facebook to Meta, etc.

This just forces the sale of TikTok to someone in the U.S.

pessimizertoday at 5:13 PM

[flagged]