logoalt Hacker News

cm2012yesterday at 10:00 PM5 repliesview on HN

This leak will also be really useful to bad actors who will resell the music from this list without paying royalties to the artists.


Replies

lkrameryesterday at 10:09 PM

Which is how Spotify started... And is still carrying on. So nothing has changed.

show 2 replies
cedwstoday at 1:12 AM

I just started DJing and something I quickly noticed is how garbage Spotify's music sounds compared to FLACs I've purchased. The max bitrate is very low.

show 2 replies
hermanzegermanyesterday at 10:52 PM

Spotify fucks over most artists anyway, so who cares?

show 2 replies
chrneuyesterday at 10:33 PM

this argument is so tired.

most artists dont really care about streaming or selling their music. most of their real money comes from touring, merch, and people somehow interacting with them.

most musicians just want to make music, express themselves, and connect with folks who enjoy their stuff or want to make music with em.

Even some of the largest artists in the world only receive a few grand a year from streaming. Only the top 1% or so of artists get enough streams to even come close to living off it. It isn't that big of a deal. Music piracy isn't the theft people think it is, lars.

youtube is kind of the same way. the real money comes from sponsorships which come from engagement. nobody on youtube is upset that their video got stolen because that mentality was never sold to us to justify screwing us over. musicians, however, were used as pawns so music labels could get more money.

now folks will say stuff like "this is theft" which is just a roundabout way of supporting labels who steal from the artists. so, it's just a weird gaslighting. there's a reason folks turned on metallica over the napster stuff. metallica were being used to further the interests of labels over the interests of fans. and now you're doing the same thing :) It's a script we hear over and over again yet people keep falling for it.

show 4 replies