alt Hacker NewsThis doesn't make any sense to me.
If you wanted to verify the contents of a dependency, you would want to check go.sum. That's what it is there for, after all. So if you wanted to fetch the dependencies, then you would want to use it to verify hashes.
If all you care about the is the versions of dependencies, you really can (and should) trust go.mod alone. You can do this because there are multiple overlapping mechanisms that all ensure that a tag is immutable once it is used:
- The Go CLI tools will of course use the go.sum file to validate that a given published version of a module can never change (at least since it was depended on, but it also is complementary with the features below as well, so it can be even better than that.)
- Let's say you rm the go.sum file. That's OK. They also default to using the Go Sum DB to verify that a given published version of a module can never change. So if a module has ever been `go get`'d by a client with the Sum DB enabled and it's publicly accessible, then it should be added to the Sum DB, and future changes to tags will cause it to be rejected.
- And even then, the module proxy is used by default too, so as soon as a published version is used by anyone, it will wind up in the proxy as long as its under a suitable license. Which means that even if you go and overwrite a tag, almost nobody will ever actually see this.
The downside is obviously all of this centralized infrastructure that is depended on, but I think it winds up being the best tradeoff; none of it is a hard dependency, even for the "dependencies should be immutable" aspect thanks to go.sum files. Instead it mostly helps dependency resolution remain fast and reproducible. Most language ecosystems have a hard dependency on centralized infrastructure, whether it is a centralized package manager service like NPM or a centralized repository on GitHub, whereas the centralized infrastructure with Go is strictly complementary and you can even use alternative instances if you want.
But digression aside, because of that, you can trust the version numbers in go.mod.
Replies
A local cache of sums are also stored in (iirc) $GOCACHE, so even if you delete go.sum from the project, the local toolchain should still be able to verify module versions previously seen without needing to call out to the Sum DB.
Probably unpopular, but I just use Bazel and pick the versions of software I use.
I know the current attitude is to just blindly trust 3rd party libraries (current and all future versions) and all of their dependencies, but I just can't accept that. This is just unsustainable.
I guess I'm old or something.
> If you wanted to verify the contents of a dependency, you would want to check go.sum
You're right, but also TFA says "There is truly no use case for ever parsing it outside of cmd/go". Since cmd/go verifies the contents of your dependencies, the point generally stands. If you don't trust cmd/go to verify a dependency, then you have a valid exception to the rule.