logoalt Hacker News

iugtmkbdfil834yesterday at 5:43 PM5 repliesview on HN

Yeah, but doesn't publishing an easily falsifiable paper end one?


Replies

bnchrchyesterday at 5:49 PM

One, it doesnt damage your reputation as much as one would think.

But two, and more importantly, no one is checking.

Tree falls in the forest, no one hears, yadi-yada.

show 2 replies
m-schuetzyesterday at 7:36 PM

The vast majority of papers is so insignifcant, nobody bothers to try and use and thereby replicate it.

parpfishyesterday at 5:48 PM

But the thing is… nobody is doing the replication to falsify it. And if the did, it wouldn’t be published because it’s a null result

wizzwizz4yesterday at 5:48 PM

Not in most fields, unless misconduct is evident. (And what constitutes "misconduct" is cultural: if you have enough influence in a community, you can exert that influence on exactly where that definitional border lies.) Being wrong is not, and should not be, a career-ending move.

show 1 reply
Telaneoyesterday at 6:19 PM

Not really, since nobody (for values of) ends up actually falsifying it, and if they do, it's years down the line.